← Back to Home

Cakes & Shuga Pies

Over 70 handcrafted flavors, baked fresh daily. Order a dozen, grab some singles, or ask about gift baskets and wholesale.

Mini Shuga Pie Dozen

Mini Shuga Pie Cakes

$47 per dozen

Choose 1 cake flavor per dozen — we can do a couple filling flavors per dozen. Want a random assortment? We'll pick from whatever we're baking that day!

Individual Shuga Pies

Individual Shuga Pies & Cakes

$6 each (most flavors)

Regular size Shuga Pies are $6 for most flavors, $7 for Rainbow Cookie, Pistachio, and Maple Bacon. Grab a few and try something new!

All Flavors

Chocolate (22)

Death by Chocolate

Triple chocolate overload with rich ganache filling

$6

Cookies & Cream

Crushed Oreo cookie cream with chocolate drizzle

$6

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Creamy peanut butter swirled with dark chocolate

🥜 $6

Chocolate Coconut

Toasted coconut folded into chocolate cream

🥥 $6

Chocolate Hazelnut

Nutella-inspired hazelnut chocolate filling

🥜 $6

S'mores

Graham cracker crust, chocolate, toasted marshmallow

$6

Brownie Batter

Fudgy brownie batter cream with chocolate chips

$6

Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Fresh strawberry cream dipped in chocolate

$6

Mud Pie

Dark chocolate pudding with cookie crumble

$6

Mexican Chocolate

Cinnamon-spiced chocolate with a hint of chili

$6

Chocolate Raspberry

Rich chocolate with fresh raspberry swirl

$6

Chocolate Crumb

Chocolate cake crumb with chocolate cream filling

$6

Original

Classic chocolate with vanilla filling — the OG

$6

Mint Chocolate Chip

Cool mint cream with chocolate chip pieces

$6

Mint Fudge Cookie

Mint fudge layered with cookie crumble

$6

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel

Chocolate and peanut butter with salty pretzel crunch

🥜 $6

Mudslide

Coffee-chocolate cream with a boozy flavor twist

$6

Chocolate Cherry

Dark chocolate cream with cherry compote

$6

German Chocolate

Chocolate with coconut pecan frosting

🥜 🥥 $6

Rocky Road

Chocolate, marshmallow, and almond pieces

🥜 $6

Chocolate Pudding Pie

Classic chocolate pudding in a crumb crust

$6

Chocolate Coffee Caramel

Espresso chocolate drizzled with caramel

$6

Fruity (33)

Strawberries & Cream

Fresh strawberry compote with vanilla cream

$6

Blueberry Swirl

Blueberry compote with lemon marmalade cream

$6

Lemon Meringue

Tart lemon curd topped with torched meringue

$6

Key Lime

Tangy key lime filling with graham cracker crust

$6

Mango Passion Fruit

Tropical mango and passion fruit mousse

$6

Raspberry White Chocolate

Fresh raspberry with white chocolate ganache

$6

Peach Cobbler

Spiced peach filling with buttery crumble

$6

Cherry Cheesecake

Classic cheesecake with cherry compote

$6

Apple Crumble

Cinnamon apple filling with oat crumble top

$6

Banana Pudding Pie

Southern-style banana pudding with vanilla wafers

$6

Strawberry Lemonade

Sweet strawberry meets tart lemonade cream

$6

Lemon

Bright and tangy lemon cream filling

$6

Lemon Crumb

Zesty lemon cream with buttery crumb topping

$6

Lemon Coconut

Lemon cream with toasted coconut flakes

🥥 $6

Lemon Poppy

Lemon cream with poppy seed crunch

$6

Lemon Blueberry

Lemon cream swirled with blueberry compote

$6

Lemon Lime

Double citrus lemon-lime cream

$6

Orange Crumb

Fresh orange cream with buttery crumb topping

$6

Orange Creamsicle

Creamy vanilla-orange swirl like the classic pop

$6

Peach Crumb

Sweet peach filling with crumb topping

$6

Peach Melba

Peach and raspberry cream with vanilla

$6

Blueberry Crumb

Fresh blueberry filling with crumb topping

$6

Cherry Lime Rickey

Cherry and lime cream — fizzy flavor in pie form

$6

Pineapple Upside Down

Caramelized pineapple with brown sugar cream

$6

Three Berry Crunch

Strawberry, blueberry, and raspberry with crunch

$6

Three Berry Lemonade

Triple berry swirl with tart lemonade cream

$6

Watermelon

Sweet watermelon cream — summer in a bite

$6

Strawberry Shortcake

Classic strawberry shortcake cream with cake pieces

$6

Banana Split

Banana, chocolate, strawberry and whipped cream

$6

Banana Choc Chip Crumb

Banana cream with chocolate chips and crumb

$6

Banana Cookie Crunch

Banana cream layered with cookie crunch

$6

Almond Raspberry

Almond cream with fresh raspberry swirl

🥜 $6

Raspberry Crumb w/ Almond

Raspberry filling with almond crumb topping

🥜 $6

Classic (21)

Funfetti

Birthday cake cream with rainbow sprinkles

$6

Vanilla Bean

Real Madagascar vanilla bean cream

$6

Vanilla Crumb

Vanilla cream with buttery crumb topping

$6

Vanilla Choc Chip Crumb

Vanilla cream with chocolate chips and crumb

$6

Viva Vanilla

Extra-creamy vanilla with a hint of sweetness

$6

Salted Caramel

Buttery caramel with flaky sea salt

$6

Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon swirl cream with cream cheese frosting

$6

Red Velvet

Classic red velvet with cream cheese filling

$6

Tiramisu

Espresso-soaked layers with mascarpone cream

$6

Cannoli

Sweet ricotta cream with chocolate chips

$6

Holy Cannoli

Extra-loaded cannoli cream with pistachios

🥜 $6

Dulce de Leche

Argentinian caramelized milk cream

$6

Butter Pecan

Toasted pecan butter cream

🥜 $6

Peanut Butter Cup

Reese's-style peanut butter and chocolate layers

🥜 $6

Peanut Butter Crumb

Creamy peanut butter with buttery crumb

🥜 $6

Peanut Butter Campfire

Peanut butter, chocolate, and toasted marshmallow

🥜 $6

Boston Cream

Vanilla custard with chocolate ganache top

$6

Snickerdoodle

Cinnamon sugar cookie cream

$6

Root Beer Float

Root beer cream with vanilla swirl

$6

French Toast Crumb

Maple cinnamon French toast with crumb topping

$6

Toasted Coconut

Creamy coconut with golden toasted flakes

🥥 $6

Specialty (18)

Rainbow Cookie

Italian tri-color almond cookie layered cake

🥜 $7

Rainbow Cookie Crumb

Rainbow cookie cream with almond crumb topping

🥜 $7

Holy Joe's

St. Joseph's Day custard-filled cream puff pie

$6

Pistachio

Real pistachio cream with crushed pistachios

🥜 $7

Strawberry Crunch

Strawberry shortcake with crunchy coating

$6

Cotton Candy

Whipped cotton candy cream in pastel swirls

$6

Birthday Cake

Confetti cake batter cream with sprinkle rim

$6

Strawberry Birthday Cake

Strawberry birthday cake cream with sprinkles

$6

Cookie Dough

Edible cookie dough chunks in vanilla cream

$6

Cookie Butter Crumb

Biscoff cookie butter cream with crumb

$6

Cookie Butter Crunch

Cookie butter cream with extra crunchy bits

$6

Brown Sugar Choc Chip Cookie Butter

Brown sugar cookie butter with chocolate chips

$6

Maple Bacon

Real maple cream with candied bacon bits

$7

Almond Joy

Coconut cream, almonds, and chocolate drizzle

🥜 🥥 $6

Espresso

Bold espresso cream for coffee lovers

$6

Espresso Crunch

Bold espresso cream with toffee bits

$6

Ice Cream Cone Sundae

Vanilla cream with cone pieces and hot fudge

$6

Unicorn Poop

Colorful swirled cream with sparkle sprinkles

$6

Seasonal / Holiday (10)

Pumpkin Spice

Autumn pumpkin cream with warm spices

$6

Eggnog

Holiday eggnog cream with nutmeg dusting

$6

Peppermint Bark

Peppermint white chocolate with candy cane

$6

Gingerbread

Warm gingerbread spice with molasses cream

$6

Cranberry Orange

Tart cranberry with fresh orange zest

$6

Carrot Cake

Spiced carrot cake cream with cream cheese

$6

Lemon Lavender

Lemon cream infused with French lavender

$6

Strawberry Champagne

Strawberry cream with a bubbly champagne twist

$6

Hot Cocoa

Rich hot cocoa cream topped with marshmallow

$6

Candy Cane

Crushed candy cane swirled into cream

$6

This isn't even the full list!

We keep adding new flavors, so if you don't see what you want, just ask! Wholesale available too.

Just let us know if we should avoid nuts, coconut, or any other allergens.