Cakes & Shuga Pies
Over 70 handcrafted flavors, baked fresh daily. Order a dozen, grab some singles, or ask about gift baskets and wholesale.
Mini Shuga Pie Cakes
$47 per dozen
Choose 1 cake flavor per dozen — we can do a couple filling flavors per dozen. Want a random assortment? We'll pick from whatever we're baking that day!
Individual Shuga Pies & Cakes
$6 each (most flavors)
Regular size Shuga Pies are $6 for most flavors, $7 for Rainbow Cookie, Pistachio, and Maple Bacon. Grab a few and try something new!
All Flavors
Chocolate (22)
Death by Chocolate
Triple chocolate overload with rich ganache filling
Cookies & Cream
Crushed Oreo cookie cream with chocolate drizzle
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Creamy peanut butter swirled with dark chocolate
Chocolate Coconut
Toasted coconut folded into chocolate cream
Chocolate Hazelnut
Nutella-inspired hazelnut chocolate filling
S'mores
Graham cracker crust, chocolate, toasted marshmallow
Brownie Batter
Fudgy brownie batter cream with chocolate chips
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Fresh strawberry cream dipped in chocolate
Mud Pie
Dark chocolate pudding with cookie crumble
Mexican Chocolate
Cinnamon-spiced chocolate with a hint of chili
Chocolate Raspberry
Rich chocolate with fresh raspberry swirl
Chocolate Crumb
Chocolate cake crumb with chocolate cream filling
Original
Classic chocolate with vanilla filling — the OG
Mint Chocolate Chip
Cool mint cream with chocolate chip pieces
Mint Fudge Cookie
Mint fudge layered with cookie crumble
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Chocolate and peanut butter with salty pretzel crunch
Mudslide
Coffee-chocolate cream with a boozy flavor twist
Chocolate Cherry
Dark chocolate cream with cherry compote
German Chocolate
Chocolate with coconut pecan frosting
Rocky Road
Chocolate, marshmallow, and almond pieces
Chocolate Pudding Pie
Classic chocolate pudding in a crumb crust
Chocolate Coffee Caramel
Espresso chocolate drizzled with caramel
Fruity (33)
Strawberries & Cream
Fresh strawberry compote with vanilla cream
Blueberry Swirl
Blueberry compote with lemon marmalade cream
Lemon Meringue
Tart lemon curd topped with torched meringue
Key Lime
Tangy key lime filling with graham cracker crust
Mango Passion Fruit
Tropical mango and passion fruit mousse
Raspberry White Chocolate
Fresh raspberry with white chocolate ganache
Peach Cobbler
Spiced peach filling with buttery crumble
Cherry Cheesecake
Classic cheesecake with cherry compote
Apple Crumble
Cinnamon apple filling with oat crumble top
Banana Pudding Pie
Southern-style banana pudding with vanilla wafers
Strawberry Lemonade
Sweet strawberry meets tart lemonade cream
Lemon
Bright and tangy lemon cream filling
Lemon Crumb
Zesty lemon cream with buttery crumb topping
Lemon Coconut
Lemon cream with toasted coconut flakes
Lemon Poppy
Lemon cream with poppy seed crunch
Lemon Blueberry
Lemon cream swirled with blueberry compote
Lemon Lime
Double citrus lemon-lime cream
Orange Crumb
Fresh orange cream with buttery crumb topping
Orange Creamsicle
Creamy vanilla-orange swirl like the classic pop
Peach Crumb
Sweet peach filling with crumb topping
Peach Melba
Peach and raspberry cream with vanilla
Blueberry Crumb
Fresh blueberry filling with crumb topping
Cherry Lime Rickey
Cherry and lime cream — fizzy flavor in pie form
Pineapple Upside Down
Caramelized pineapple with brown sugar cream
Three Berry Crunch
Strawberry, blueberry, and raspberry with crunch
Three Berry Lemonade
Triple berry swirl with tart lemonade cream
Watermelon
Sweet watermelon cream — summer in a bite
Strawberry Shortcake
Classic strawberry shortcake cream with cake pieces
Banana Split
Banana, chocolate, strawberry and whipped cream
Banana Choc Chip Crumb
Banana cream with chocolate chips and crumb
Banana Cookie Crunch
Banana cream layered with cookie crunch
Almond Raspberry
Almond cream with fresh raspberry swirl
Raspberry Crumb w/ Almond
Raspberry filling with almond crumb topping
Classic (21)
Funfetti
Birthday cake cream with rainbow sprinkles
Vanilla Bean
Real Madagascar vanilla bean cream
Vanilla Crumb
Vanilla cream with buttery crumb topping
Vanilla Choc Chip Crumb
Vanilla cream with chocolate chips and crumb
Viva Vanilla
Extra-creamy vanilla with a hint of sweetness
Salted Caramel
Buttery caramel with flaky sea salt
Cinnamon Roll
Cinnamon swirl cream with cream cheese frosting
Red Velvet
Classic red velvet with cream cheese filling
Tiramisu
Espresso-soaked layers with mascarpone cream
Cannoli
Sweet ricotta cream with chocolate chips
Holy Cannoli
Extra-loaded cannoli cream with pistachios
Dulce de Leche
Argentinian caramelized milk cream
Butter Pecan
Toasted pecan butter cream
Peanut Butter Cup
Reese's-style peanut butter and chocolate layers
Peanut Butter Crumb
Creamy peanut butter with buttery crumb
Peanut Butter Campfire
Peanut butter, chocolate, and toasted marshmallow
Boston Cream
Vanilla custard with chocolate ganache top
Snickerdoodle
Cinnamon sugar cookie cream
Root Beer Float
Root beer cream with vanilla swirl
French Toast Crumb
Maple cinnamon French toast with crumb topping
Toasted Coconut
Creamy coconut with golden toasted flakes
Specialty (18)
Rainbow Cookie
Italian tri-color almond cookie layered cake
Rainbow Cookie Crumb
Rainbow cookie cream with almond crumb topping
Holy Joe's
St. Joseph's Day custard-filled cream puff pie
Pistachio
Real pistachio cream with crushed pistachios
Strawberry Crunch
Strawberry shortcake with crunchy coating
Cotton Candy
Whipped cotton candy cream in pastel swirls
Birthday Cake
Confetti cake batter cream with sprinkle rim
Strawberry Birthday Cake
Strawberry birthday cake cream with sprinkles
Cookie Dough
Edible cookie dough chunks in vanilla cream
Cookie Butter Crumb
Biscoff cookie butter cream with crumb
Cookie Butter Crunch
Cookie butter cream with extra crunchy bits
Brown Sugar Choc Chip Cookie Butter
Brown sugar cookie butter with chocolate chips
Maple Bacon
Real maple cream with candied bacon bits
Almond Joy
Coconut cream, almonds, and chocolate drizzle
Espresso
Bold espresso cream for coffee lovers
Espresso Crunch
Bold espresso cream with toffee bits
Ice Cream Cone Sundae
Vanilla cream with cone pieces and hot fudge
Unicorn Poop
Colorful swirled cream with sparkle sprinkles
Seasonal / Holiday (10)
Pumpkin Spice
Autumn pumpkin cream with warm spices
Eggnog
Holiday eggnog cream with nutmeg dusting
Peppermint Bark
Peppermint white chocolate with candy cane
Gingerbread
Warm gingerbread spice with molasses cream
Cranberry Orange
Tart cranberry with fresh orange zest
Carrot Cake
Spiced carrot cake cream with cream cheese
Lemon Lavender
Lemon cream infused with French lavender
Strawberry Champagne
Strawberry cream with a bubbly champagne twist
Hot Cocoa
Rich hot cocoa cream topped with marshmallow
Candy Cane
Crushed candy cane swirled into cream
This isn't even the full list!
We keep adding new flavors, so if you don't see what you want, just ask! Wholesale available too.
Just let us know if we should avoid nuts, coconut, or any other allergens.
Or call us at (631) 669-1069