Pre-Order By Wed, March 25th, 6pm deadline!
Call 631-669-1069 or email ShugaPieShop@gmail.com (incl Phone #)
Pick up only on Sat, April 4th, 11am–4pm
Closed Easter Day!
Didn't Preorder? No Problem!
Flavors available for same day purchase.
Carrot Cake
$6Spiced carrot cake cream with cream cheese (no raisins)
Cookies & Cream
$6Crushed Oreo cookie cream with chocolate drizzle
Espresso
$6Bold espresso cream for coffee lovers
Rainbow Cookie
$7Italian tri-color almond cookie layered cake
Funfetti
$6Birthday cake cream with rainbow sprinkles
Death By Chocolate
$6Triple chocolate overload with rich ganache filling
Pistachio Chocolate Chip
$7Pistachio cream studded with chocolate chips
Cookie Butter Cinnamon Roll
$6Biscoff cookie butter swirled with cinnamon roll cream
Chocolate Lavender
$6Rich chocolate cream infused with French lavender
Choc. Brown Sugar Choc Chip w/Caramel
$6Brown sugar chocolate chip cream drizzled with caramel
Strawberry Crunch
$6Strawberry shortcake with crunchy coating
Blueberry Cobbler
$6Fresh blueberry cobbler filling with crumb topping
Cinnamon Molasses Crumb
$6Warm cinnamon molasses cream with buttery crumb
Chocolate Marshmallow Brownie
$6Fudgy brownie cream with toasted marshmallow swirl
Lemon Custard
$6Silky lemon custard cream filling
Chocolate Choc Chip Cookie Dough
$6Chocolate cream loaded with cookie dough chunks
Peanut Butter Cup
$6Reese's-style peanut butter and chocolate layers
Cotton Tails
$6Pastel swirls with marshmallow — an Easter favorite
Italian Cream Cake w/Raspberry
$6Italian cream cake with raspberry, almonds, and coconut
Looking for something specific? We love custom holiday orders.
Contact Us for Custom Orders