Babylon Village, NY
Handcrafted Mini
Pie‑Cakes, Baked
Fresh Daily
Over 60 rotating flavors of artisanal mini pie-cakes — from Death by Chocolate to Rainbow Cookie. Pick up fresh at our shop or order ahead.
Today's Flavors
Death by Chocolate
$6Triple chocolate overload with rich ganache filling
Cookies & Cream
$6Crushed Oreo cookie cream with chocolate drizzle
Chocolate Peanut Butter
$6Creamy peanut butter swirled with dark chocolate
Strawberries & Cream
$6Fresh strawberry compote with vanilla cream
Blueberry Swirl
$6Blueberry compote with lemon marmalade cream
Lemon Meringue
$6Tart lemon curd topped with torched meringue
Holiday Flavors
Didn't preorder? No problem — flavors available for same day purchase!
Carrot Cake
$6Spiced carrot cake cream with cream cheese (no raisins)
Cookies & Cream
$6Crushed Oreo cookie cream with chocolate drizzle
Espresso
$6Bold espresso cream for coffee lovers
Rainbow Cookie
$7Italian tri-color almond cookie layered cake
Funfetti
$6Birthday cake cream with rainbow sprinkles
Death By Chocolate
$6Triple chocolate overload with rich ganache filling
Special Orders
Mini Shuga Pie Dozen
$47/dozen12 handcrafted mini pie-cakes in your choice of flavor. Perfect for parties, gifts, or treating yourself.
Order a Dozen
Gift Baskets
From $35Beautifully arranged assortments of our best-selling flavors. A sweet surprise for any occasion.
View Baskets
Seasonal Specials
VariesLimited-time flavors that celebrate the season. Ask about our holiday collections and custom orders.
See SpecialsHow It Works
Pick Your Flavors
Browse our rotating daily menu of 60+ handcrafted flavors
Order Ahead
Call or visit us to place your order for pickup
Pick Up Fresh
Grab your freshly baked pie-cakes from our Babylon Village shop
From Our Kitchen
to Your Table
What started as a passion for baking has grown into Babylon Village's favorite spot for handcrafted mini pie-cakes. Every single pie is made from scratch with premium ingredients — never mass-produced, never frozen.
With over 60 rotating flavors, there's always something new to try. From our signature Death by Chocolate to seasonal favorites, each bite is a little piece of joy we're proud to share with our community.
Come Visit UsOur Customers Love Us