Assorted shuga pies

Babylon Village, NY

Handcrafted Mini
Pie‑Cakes, Baked
Fresh Daily

Over 60 rotating flavors of artisanal mini pie-cakes β€” from Death by Chocolate to Rainbow Cookie. Pick up fresh at our shop or order ahead.

Fresh from the oven

Today's Flavors

See All Today's Flavors
Limited time

Holiday Flavors

Didn't preorder? No problem β€” flavors available for same day purchase!

See All Holiday Flavors
Simple as pie

How It Works

Pick Your Flavors

Browse our rotating daily menu of 60+ handcrafted flavors

Order Ahead

Call or visit us to place your order for pickup

Pick Up Fresh

Grab your freshly baked pie-cakes from our Babylon Village shop

Inside The Shuga Pie Shop
Our Story

From Our Kitchen
to Your Table

What started as a passion for baking has grown into Babylon Village's favorite spot for handcrafted mini pie-cakes. Every single pie is made from scratch with premium ingredients β€” never mass-produced, never frozen.

With over 60 rotating flavors, there's always something new to try. From our signature Death by Chocolate to seasonal favorites, each bite is a little piece of joy we're proud to share with our community.

Come Visit Us
What people say

Our Customers Love Us

"The Death by Chocolate is absolutely incredible. I ordered two dozen for my daughter's birthday and every single one was gone within an hour!"

Sarah M.

"Best bakery on Long Island, hands down. The Rainbow Cookie pie-cake is out of this world. We order every weekend now."

Mike D.

"Ordered gift baskets for my office holiday party. Everyone was raving about them! The variety of flavors is amazing and they're all delicious."

Jessica L.

"We drive 30 minutes just to get these pies. The Strawberry Crunch and Banana Pudding are our favorites. Worth every mile!"

Tom R.

Follow along

@shugapieshop

Fresh bakes, behind the scenes, and more on Instagram